| 2024 |
| Fri., Sep. 20 | vs. Pinson Valley | W 25-19 (OT) | R |
| 2022 |
| Fri., Aug. 26 | @ Fairfield | W 34-28 (2OT) | R |
| 2017 |
| Fri., Sep. 29 | @ Pinson Valley | L 27-28 (OT) | R |
| 2006 |
| Thu., Sep. 21 | @ Huffman | L 10-16 (OT) | R @ Lawson Field |
| 2000 |
| Fri., Sep. 22 | @ Brewer | W 17-10 (OT) | R |
| 1998 |
| Fri., Nov. 27 | @ Vestavia Hills | L 35-42 (OT) | Semi-finals Playoffs |
| 1996 |
| Fri., Sep. 20 | vs. Homewood | L 21-27 (OT) | R |
| 1995 |
| Fri., Oct. 13 | @ Benjamin Russell | W 35-28 (2OT) | R |
| 1990 |
| Fri., Sep. 14 | @ Tuscaloosa County | L 17-20 (OT) | R |
| 1987 |
| Fri., Sep. 4 | vs. Tuscaloosa County | L 24-25 (2OT) | R | | Fri., Nov. 13 | @ Huntsville | W 17-16 (OT) | 2nd Round Playoffs @ Milton Frank |
| 1984 |
| Fri., Oct. 12 | vs. Mountain Brook | L 13-16 (2OT) | R |
| 1980 |
| Fri., Sep. 19 | vs. John Carroll | T 20-20 (OT) | R | | Fri., Oct. 3 | vs. Homewood | W 13-12 (OT) | R | | Fri., Oct. 17 | @ Berry | W 27-24 (3OT) | R |
| 1979 |
| Fri., Oct. 26 | @ Vestavia Hills | L 24-27 (OT) | R |
| 1978 |
| Fri., Sep. 29 | vs. Homewood | W 17-14 (OT) | R |
| 1975 |
| Fri., Oct. 3 | @ Homewood | W 27-24 (OT) | R |
|
| Shades Valley Overtime Totals |
| Record |
9-8-1 403-396 |
| Home Record | 3-3 |
| Away Record | 6-5 |
|