| Class: 4A |
| |
| Round 1 |
| 4/30/1991 | Tallassee  9-0 Beaureguard |
| 4/30/1991 | Daleville  4-3 Pike County |
| 4/30/1991 | Daphne  9-1 Clarke County |
| 4/30/1991 | Headland  10-9 Ashford |
| 4/30/1991 | Montevallo  7-3 Greensboro |
| 4/30/1991 | B.B. Comer  10-3 Livingston |
| 4/30/1991 | Dadeville  9-0 Lanett |
| 4/30/1991 | Thomasville  8-7 W.S. Neal |
| 4/30/1991 | Pleasant Grove  13-3 Corner |
| 4/30/1991 | Winfield  10-9 North Jackson |
| 4/30/1991 | Deshler  4-2 Wilson |
| 4/30/1991 | Alexandria  5-1 Glencoe |
| 4/30/1991 | Sheffield  5-4 Colbert County |
| 4/30/1991 | Hokes Bluff  3-0 Lincoln |
| 4/30/1991 | Haleyville  9-5 Buckhorn |
| 4/30/1991 | Mortimer Jordan  5-2 Tarrant |
| |
| Round 2 |
| 5/2/1991 | Tallassee   Thomasville |
| 5/2/1991 | Daphne   Dadeville |
| 5/2/1991 | Daleville  8-0 Montevallo |
| 5/2/1991 | Headland   B.B. Comer |
| 5/2/1991 | Pleasant Grove  15-5 Winfield |
| 5/2/1991 | Deshler  3-2 Alexandria |
| 5/2/1991 | Sheffield  3-1 Hokes Bluff |
| 5/2/1991 | Haleyville  5-4 Mortimer Jordan |
| |
| Round 3 |
| 5/4/1991 | Tallassee  5-0 Daleville |
| 5/4/1991 | Daphne  12-4 Headland |
| 5/4/1991 | Sheffield  9-3 Haleyville |
| 5/4/1991 | Pleasant Grove  8-4 Deshler |
| |
| Semi-Finals |
| 5/10/1991 | Tallassee  (4-1, 3-2) Daphne Tallassee wins series (2-0) |
| 5/10/1991 | Pleasant Grove  (5-1, 3-6, 7-4) Sheffield Pleasant Grove wins series (2-1) |
| |
| Finals |
| 5/17/1991 | Tallassee  (2-4, 3-1, 7-5) Pleasant Grove Tallassee wins series (2-1) |
| |