| 2020 |
| Fri., Nov. 6 | Bye | - | 1st Round Playoffs | | Fri., Nov. 13 | @ Greenfield | W 14-12 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | Fri., Nov. 20 | @ Lake County | L 8-42 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 2019 |
| Fri., Nov. 8 | vs. Memphis East | W 62-36 | 1st Round Playoffs | | Fri., Nov. 15 | @ Middle College | W 28-14 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | Fri., Nov. 22 | @ Lake County | L 0-46 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 2018 |
| Fri., Nov. 2 | @ Hillcrest | W 47-28 | 1st Round Playoffs | | Fri., Nov. 9 | @ Lake County | L 0-48 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 2012 |
| Sat., Nov. 10 | vs. Halls | W 28-13 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | Fri., Nov. 16 | vs. Huntingdon | L 6-37 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 2011 |
| Fri., Nov. 11 | vs. Gleason | W 35-14 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | Fri., Nov. 18 | vs. Union City | W 21-20 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | Fri., Nov. 25 | @ Wayne County | L 0-33 | Semi-finals Playoffs |
| 2009 |
| | Lake County | L 26-33 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2005 |
| | Jackson Christian | L 18-48 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2004 |
| | Perry County | W 38-13 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jackson Christian | L 14-18 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 2003 |
| | Trinity Christian | L 21-29 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2002 |
| | Jackson Christian | L 12-15 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2000 |
| | Perry County | W 68-8 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Hollow Rock-Bruceton | L 0-32 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 1999 |
| | Hollow Rock-Bruceton | L 0-42 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1998 |
| | Dresden | W 17-14 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Jackson Christian | L 0-6 | 2nd Round Playoffs |
| 1997 |
| | South Fulton | L 0-14 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1993 |
| | USJ | L 3-28 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1990 |
| | Halls | L 14-18 | 1st Round Playoffs |
|
| West Carroll Playoff Totals |
| Record |
10-16-0 480-661 |
| Home Record | 4-1 |
| Away Record | 3-4 |
|
