| 2018 |
| Sat., Nov. 3 | @ Briarcrest | L 15-42 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2017 |
| Fri., Nov. 3 | @ Memphis University | L 0-49 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2016 |
| Fri., Nov. 4 | @ Christian Brothers | L 18-43 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2015 |
| Fri., Nov. 6 | @ Briarcrest | L 18-40 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2014 |
| Fri., Nov. 7 | vs. Briarcrest | L 20-23 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2013 |
| Fri., Nov. 8 | @ Christian Brothers | L 6-35 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2012 |
| Fri., Nov. 2 | @ McCallie | L 20-62 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2011 |
| | Father Ryan | L 0-17 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2010 |
| | BGA | L 7-36 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2009 |
| | Baylor | L 10-42 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2004 |
| | ECS | L 7-35 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2003 |
| | ECS | L 6-42 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2002 |
| | Briarcrest | L 0-44 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 2001 |
| | Briarcrest | L 7-44 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1998 |
| | Briarcrest | L 3-31 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1997 |
| | ECS | L 14-34 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1996 |
| | South Fulton | W 14-0 | 1st Round Playoffs | | | Nashville Christian | W 17-0 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Lake County | W 21-6 | 3rd Round Playoffs | | | Moore County | W 7-6 | Semi-finals Playoffs | | | DCA | L 3-51 | Championship Game |
| 1995 |
| | Dresden | L 0-19 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1994 |
| | Lake County | L 3-42 | 1st Round Playoffs |
| 1993 |
| | Wayne County | W 21-7 | 2nd Round Playoffs | | | Hollow Rock-Bruceton | L 6-7 | 3rd Round Playoffs |
| 1992 |
| | USJ | L 6-28 | 1st Round Playoffs |
|
| St. Benedict Playoff Totals |
| Record |
5-21-0 249-785 |
| Home Record | 0-1 |
| Away Record | 0-6 |
|
