|
Note: You must be registered in order to post a reply.
To register, click here. Registration is FREE!
|
| T O P I C R E V I E W |
| mole7673 |
Posted - 01/05/2024 : 09:41:24
I did a study of the playoffs and found some interesting statistics that some of y'all may be interested in.
Of the 260 county schools in the state, 124 made the playoffs. (48%)
Of the 92 city schools in the state, 59 made the playoffs. (64%)
Of the 36 private schools in the state, 25 made the playoffs. (69%)
7-A had 4 county schools and 12 city schools.
6-A had 13 county, 17 city and 2 private schools.
5-A had 16 county, 13 city and 3 private schools.
4-A had 16 county, 9 city and 7 private schools.
3-A had 19 county, 5 city and 8 private schools.
2-A had 29 county, 1 city and 2 private schools.
1-A had 27 county, 2 city and 3 private schools.
I know that competitive balance is always a hot topic when reclassification comes up. These statistics seem to indicate an advantage with city schools as well as private schools based on the percentages.
Question for the forum: In the past private schools have been made out to be the boogeyman and have been the only school subgroup that's had to deal with competitive balance. Should city schools fall under competitive balance as well based on the statistics? Should all schools, county, city, private be included in competitive balance?
I's like to get some feedback because I know that competitive balance always comes up during a reclassification period.
Thanks!
|
| 10 L A T E S T R E P L I E S (Newest First) |
| powerlineman |
Posted - 01/12/2024 : 23:22:37
If that doesn?t pass that will be the end of the AISA. This will be the only thing to give them a chance |
| spartan91 |
Posted - 01/12/2024 : 19:24:54
Now look. There's no reason that this should not pass. https://www.riverregionsports.com/stories/aisa-applies-for-membership-in-national-high-school-federation |
| spartan91 |
Posted - 01/07/2024 : 15:45:08
One word-- Geography. The schools that have left the AISA lately have been the larger schools that have been having to travel to play the other 3A schools in the AISA.
As I've pointed out on this forum before, the AHSAA is the only associaion in the Southeast that does not allow it's members to play crossover games with non-member schools in state. It would seem logical to give the private schools an option. quote:
Originally posted by Bum Pickins
Why do private schools want to be in the AHSAA if they are getting a raw deal?
Also, I wish the AHSAA would release the number of transfers per school.
|
| GiglnTiger |
Posted - 01/07/2024 : 08:04:42
Mole, its worth noting that the bulk of your private schools are in 3A-4A & the bulk of your city schools are sitting in the higher classifications. I believe that the private & city schools are for most part all within geographical placement (metro areas of larger cities) of each other, except for the BHAM metro area (I cant think of a private athletic program in there, its all city).
_____________
Jeremy Wortham
(former RCHS student-athlete 2000-2003)
Randolph County Tigers
2003 Class 2A State Champions
2017 Class 3A State Runner-Ups, 1998 Class 3A State Runner-Ups,
1984 Class 3A State Runner-Ups, 1979 Class 2A State Runner-Ups |
| hthe3 |
Posted - 01/07/2024 : 05:57:33
quote:
Originally posted by Bum Pickins
Why do private schools want to be in the AHSAA if they are getting a raw deal?
Also, I wish the AHSAA would release the number of transfers per school.
I don't think there is a polite way of putting it, but: legitimacy and competition.
When/where I was in school, a lot of the private schools were never in the AISA and there were not enough to form a bigger non-AISA private school league. Can't really call yourself a state champion with a straight face if you're only playing 5 other schools every year.
So I'm sure there is a major administrative factor here that I'm not clued in to. The AHSAA private schools probably felt that the AHSAA was better run/had disagreements with the AISA.
Now that the AISA is falling apart, the AHSAA is the only stable body. Maybe there will be a push for a new private school league after if folds but I don't know that the schools are laid out evenly enough geographically/enrollment wise to make a cohesive league. I think some of the AISA schools are struggling budget wise and are hopping to the AHSAA so they can play closer located public schools and reduce travel costs. |
| Bum Pickins |
Posted - 01/06/2024 : 17:10:02
Why do private schools want to be in the AHSAA if they are getting a raw deal?
Also, I wish the AHSAA would release the number of transfers per school. |
| jmcgill56 |
Posted - 01/05/2024 : 13:24:33
quote:
Originally posted by BamaJoe
quote:
Originally posted by jmcgill56
If someone had the time and the statistics to do this, I would be interested to see a similar study using the socioeconomic status of the area surrounding the schools and that of the students' households. I suspect there would be a positive correlation between all classifications of success in sports and higher socioeconomic status. This would not always be the case. But, I believe one would see that correlation with a study done with lots of data over many years.
I think you are probably correct. There will be outliers for sure. This factors in to why I think private schools should have their own deal.
Go Eagles!
I've wondered if we would ever go the private school separate playoffs route in Alabama but I just don't see it happening yet until there are more private schools that are competitive. |
| hthe3 |
Posted - 01/05/2024 : 10:48:31
quote:
Originally posted by jmcgill56
If someone had the time and the statistics to do this, I would be interested to see a similar study using the socioeconomic status of the area surrounding the schools and that of the students' households. I suspect there would be a positive correlation between all classifications of success in sports and higher socioeconomic status. This would not always be the case. But, I believe one would see that correlation with a study done with lots of data over many years.
I think that would be a really interesting study. Wealthier schools, public or private, probably have an easier time building youth/middle school leagues for development and their players probably have better access to transportation so they can participate more easily over the summer for workouts.
I recall reading about Central-Coosa struggling to get numbers several years ago because kids just could not be there to participate. No in county competition, but the kids were so spread out they couldn't really get to the school if the bus didn't take them or if they didn't have a ride. |
| BamaJoe |
Posted - 01/05/2024 : 10:39:02
quote:
Originally posted by jmcgill56
If someone had the time and the statistics to do this, I would be interested to see a similar study using the socioeconomic status of the area surrounding the schools and that of the students' households. I suspect there would be a positive correlation between all classifications of success in sports and higher socioeconomic status. This would not always be the case. But, I believe one would see that correlation with a study done with lots of data over many years.
I think you are probably correct. There will be outliers for sure. This factors in to why I think private schools should have their own deal.
Go Eagles! |
| jmcgill56 |
Posted - 01/05/2024 : 10:27:38
If someone had the time and the statistics to do this, I would be interested to see a similar study using the socioeconomic status of the area surrounding the schools and that of the students' households. I suspect there would be a positive correlation between all classifications of success in sports and higher socioeconomic status. This would not always be the case. But, I believe one would see that correlation with a study done with lots of data over many years. |
|
|
| AHSFHS.org Forums |
© 2007-09 AHSFHS.org |
 |
|
| This page was generated in 0.04 seconds. |
 |
|
|
|
