| Team |
City |
First Season |
All-Time |
| Valdosta
| Valdosta, GA | 1913 | 973-271-34 |
| Mayfield
* | Mayfield, KY | 1919 | 969-267-32 |
| Male
| Louisville, KY | 1893 | 966-354-47 |
| Massillon
| Massillon, OH | 1891 | 964-306-36 |
| Fort Thomas Highlands
| Fort Thomas, KY | 1915 | 953-280-26 |
| Mount Carmel
| Mount Carmel, PA | 1893 | 938-369-28 |
| Highland Park
| Dallas, TX | 1923 | 925-281-24 |
| Muskegon
* | Muskegon, MI | 1895 | 910-298-43 |
| |
| Easton
| Easton, PA | 1889 | 900-391-31 |
| Canton McKinley
| Canton, OH | 1894 | 897-383-49 |
| Haynesville
* | Haynesville, LA | 1907 | 894-313-34 |
| Ansonia
| Ansonia, CT | 1890 | 884-249-57 |
| Steubenville
| Steubenville, OH | 1900 | 882-337-37 |
| Maryville
| Maryville, TN | 1926 | 877-241-35 |
| Shelby
| Shelby, NC | 1910 | 871-322-42 |
| Clinton
* | Clinton, OK | 1919 | 868-315-37 |
| |
| Hampton
| Hampton, VA | 1899 | 862-302-48 |
| Summerville
| Summerville, SC | 1909 | 856-276-30 |
| Berwick
| Berwick, PA | 1888 | 855-371-22 |
| Parkersburg
| Parkersburg, WV | 1900 | 855-383-40 |
| East St. Louis
| East St. Louis, IL | 1925 | 855-211-36 |
| Steelton Highspire
| Steelton, PA | 1894 | 854-453-58 |
| Paducah Tilghman
* | Paducah, KY | 1904 | 853-359-34 |
| Mart
| Mart, TX | 1912 | 853-366-45 |
| |
| Ada
* | Ada, OK | 1912 | 853-365-24 |
| Everett
* | Everett, MA | 1893 | 852-395-79 |
| Long Beach Poly
* | Long Beach, CA | 1904 | 848-349-52 |
| Nashville
| Nashville, AR | 1910 | 845-366-27 |
| Gaffney
| Gaffney, SC | 1921 | 845-365-30 |
| Dobyns-Bennett
| Kingsport, TN | 1921 | 845-272-28 |
| Reidsville
* | Reidsville, NC | 1920 | 843-326-38 |
| Bakersfield
* | Bakersfield, CA | 1896 | 838-301-43 |
| |
| Lawton
* | Lawton, OK | 1902 | 834-396-34 |
| Brockton
| Brockton, MA | 1897 | 834-424-64 |
| Louisville St. Xavier
* | Louisville, KY | 1917 | 832-326-20 |
| Chicago Mount Carmel
| Chicago, IL | 1924 | 831-258-30 |
| Pine Bluff
| Pine Bluff, AR | 1901 | 831-400-54 |
| B.T. Washington
* | Tulsa, OK | 1922 | 830-257-30 |
| Danville
| Danville, KY | 1909 | 829-328-35 |
| Leominster
* | Leominster, MA | 1894 | 828-444-64 |
| |
| Amarillo
| Amarillo, TX | 1908 | 828-387-22 |
| Owensboro
| Owensboro, KY | 1895 | 822-403-31 |
| LaGrange
| LaGrange, GA | 1905 | 820-394-40 |
| Refugio
| Refugio, TX | 1931 | 818-278-29 |
| Sioux Falls Washington
* | Sioux Falls, SD | 1899 | 817-371-38 |
| Temple
| Temple, TX | 1905 | 814-383-52 |
| New Britain
* | New Britain, CT | 1892 | 813-381-50 |
| Little Rock Central
| Little Rock, AR | 1904 | 810-424-48 |
| |
| Cuero
| Cuero, TX | 1911 | 810-395-35 |
| Mount Airy
* | Mount Airy, NC | 1915 | 808-333-34 |
| Montgomery Bell Academy
| Nashville, TN | 1899 | 804-379-46 |
| Gainesville
| Gainesville, GA | 1905 | 804-360-25 |
| Alcoa
| Alcoa, TN | 1924 | 801-297-23 |
| Neville
* | Monroe, LA | 1931 | 800-266-14 |
| Longview
| Longview, TX | 1909 | 799-363-51 |
| Aliquippa
| Aliquippa, PA | 1910 | 799-334-42 |
| |
| Plano
| Plano, TX | 1904 | 797-405-47 |
| Louisville
* | Louisville, MS | 1915 | 796-305-27 |
| Marist
| Atlanta, GA | 1912 | 795-341-38 |
| Cathedral
* | Indianapolis, IN | 1919 | 794-311-19 |
| Jeannette
| Jeannette, PA | 1900 | 794-345-41 |
| Jenks
* | Jenks, OK | 1920 | 794-279-29 |
| Booneville
| Booneville, AR | 1920 | 794-353-35 |
| Brownwood
| Brownwood, TX | 1907 | 793-415-34 |
| |
| Rockhurst
| Kansas City, MO | 1916 | 787-270-35 |
| Lawrence
* | Lawrence, KS | 1891 | 786-326-41 |
| Wyoming
* | Cincinnati, OH | 1920 | 786-227-48 |
| Harlan
* | Harlan, IA | 1923 | 784-301-43 |
| Thomasville
| Thomasville, GA | 1914 | 780-374-46 |
| Baylor
| Chattanooga, TN | 1908 | 777-351-42 |
| Albany
| Albany, TX | 1917 | 777-346-27 |
| Greenwood
| Greenwood, SC | 1909 | 776-348-53 |
| |
| Starkville
| Starkville, MS | 1919 | 775-289-28 |
| Montclair
| Montclair, NJ | 1896 | 775-380-54 |
| Woodard Academy
| College Park, GA | 1902 | 774-434-42 |
| Marquette University
* | Milwaukee, WI | 1907 | 772-303-34 |
| Bowling Green
* | Bowling Green, KY | 1922 | 771-363-35 |
| New Castle
| New Castle, PA | 1892 | 768-446-69 |
| Blazer
| Ashland, KY | 1900 | 767-436-43 |
| Wilmette
| Wilmette, IL | 1909 | 767-372-42 |
| |
| C.H. Yoe
| Cameron, TX | 1911 | 765-399-44 |
| Abbeville
| Abbeville, SC | 1915 | 764-340-28 |
| Coatesville
| Coatesville, PA | 1903 | 764-428-50 |
| Gilmer
| Gilmer, TX | 1914 | 763-412-38 |
| Carrollton
| Carrollton, GA | 1909 | 763-256-30 |
| Jesuit New Orleans
* | New Orleans, LA | 1920 | 763-385-34 |
| Tuscola
| Tuscola, IL | 1895 | 762-352-42 |
| Thomas-Fay-Custer
* | Thomas, OK | 1920 | 761-224-11 |
| |
| Creighton Prep
* | Omaha, NE | 1920 | 760-251-23 |
| Dillon
| Dillon, SC | 1915 | 759-345-25 |
| Reitz
| Evansville, IN | 1918 | 755-306-30 |
| St. Louis
* | Honolulu, HI | 1920 | 754-285-38 |
| Cartersville
| Cartersville, GA | 1909 | 754-334-30 |
| Ann Arbor Pioneer
* | Ann Arbor, MI | 1915 | 754-482-38 |
| Washington
| Washington, PA | 1901 | 753-388-57 |
| Williamsport
| Williamsport, PA | 1892 | 752-513-28 |
| |
| Martins Ferry
| Martins Ferry, OH | 1899 | 751-425-42 |
| Christian Brothers
| Memphis, TN | 1894 | 751-382-40 |
| North Medford
* | Medford, OR | 1900 | 746-319-34 |
| John Tyler
| Tyler, TX | 1908 | 745-429-43 |
| T.R. Miller
| Brewton, AL | 1926 | 744-341-20 |
| Seminole
* | Seminole, OK | 1900 | 744-396-55 |
| Lufkin
| Lufkin, TX | 1911 | 744-379-38 |
| Whitehaven
| Memphis, TN | 1925 | 744-308-19 |
| |
| Lake View
| Lake View, SC | 1925 | 744-317-17 |
| Hartsville
| Hartsville, SC | 1914 | 737-396-27 |
| Corsicana
| Corsicana, TX | 1909 | 736-441-45 |
| William Penn
| Philadelphia, PA | 1887 | 734-398-53 |
| Oneonta
| Oneonta, AL | 1907 | 733-380-33 |
| Wheaton
* | Wheaton, IL | 1912 | 731-319-26 |
| Fayette County
| Fayette, AL | 1914 | 730-381-35 |
| St. Ignatius
* | Cleveland, OH | 1920 | 730-357-32 |
| |
| Philadelphia Central
| Philadelphia, PA | 1887 | 728-478-62 |
| Meridian
| Meridian, MS | 1908 | 727-352-45 |
| Arcola
| Arcola, IL | 1894 | 719-342-30 |
| Somerset
| Somerset, KY | 1909 | 714-456-42 |
| Huntingdon
| Huntingdon, PA | 1907 | 712-424-39 |
| Harding
| Warren, OH | 1919 | 703-456-49 |
| |
| |
| * Incomplete Research |
| |
|
