| Season |
Bowl |
Date |
Bowl Matchup |
| 2024 | Alamo | 12/28/2024 | Brigham Young 36-14 Colorado |
| 2022 | New Mexico | 12/17/2022 | Brigham Young 24-23 Southern Methodist |
| 2021 | Independence | 12/18/2021 | Alabama Birmingham 31-28 Brigham Young |
| 2020 | Boca Raton | 12/22/2020 | Brigham Young 49-23 Central Florida |
| 2019 | Hawaii | 12/24/2019 | Hawaii 38-34 Brigham Young |
| 2018 | Famous Idaho Potato | 12/21/2018 | Brigham Young 49-18 Western Michigan |
| 2016 | Poinsettia | 12/21/2016 | Brigham Young 24-21 Wyoming |
| 2015 | Royal Purple | 12/19/2015 | Utah 35-28 Brigham Young |
| 2014 | Miami Beach | 12/22/2014 | Memphis 55-48 Brigham Young |
| 2013 | Fight Hunger | 12/27/2013 | Washington 31-16 Brigham Young |
| 2012 | Poinsettia | 12/20/2012 | Brigham Young 23-6 San Diego State |
| 2011 | Armed Forces | 12/30/2011 | Brigham Young 24-21 Tulsa |
| 2010 | New Mexico | 12/18/2010 | Brigham Young 52-24 Texas El Paso |
| 2009 | Las Vegas Bowl | 12/22/2009 | Brigham Young 44-20 Oregon State |
| 2007 | Las Vegas | 12/22/2007 | Brigham Young 17-16 UCLA |
| 2006 | Las Vegas | 12/21/2006 | Brigham Young 38-8 Oregon |
| 2005 | Las Vegas | 12/22/2005 | California 35-28 Brigham Young |
| 2001 | Liberty | 12/31/2001 | Louisville 28-10 Brigham Young |
| 1999 | Motor City | 12/27/1999 | Marshall 21-3 Brigham Young |
| 1998 | Liberty | 12/31/1998 | Tulane 41-27 Brigham Young |
| 1996 | Cotton | 1/1/1997 | Brigham Young 19-15 Kansas State |
| 1994 | Insight | 12/29/1994 | Brigham Young 31-6 Oklahoma |
| 1993 | Holiday | 12/30/1993 | Ohio State 28-21 Brigham Young |
| 1992 | Aloha Classic | 12/25/1992 | Kansas 23-20 Brigham Young |
| 1991 | Holiday | 12/30/1991 | Iowa 13-13 Brigham Young |
| 1990 | Holiday | 12/29/1990 | Texas A&M 65-14 Brigham Young |
| 1989 | Holiday | 12/29/1989 | Penn State 50-39 Brigham Young |
| 1988 | Freedom | 12/29/1988 | Brigham Young 20-17 Colorado |
| 1987 | All-American | 12/22/1987 | Virginia 22-16 Brigham Young |
| 1986 | Freedom | 12/30/1986 | UCLA 31-10 Brigham Young |
| 1985 | Capital One | 12/28/1985 | Ohio State 10-7 Brigham Young |
| 1984 | Holiday | 12/21/1984 | Brigham Young 24-17 Michigan |
| 1983 | Holiday | 12/23/1983 | Brigham Young 21-17 Missouri |
| 1982 | Holiday | 12/17/1982 | Ohio State 47-17 Brigham Young |
| 1981 | Holiday | 12/18/1981 | Brigham Young 38-36 Washington State |
| 1980 | Holiday | 12/19/1980 | Brigham Young 46-45 Southern Methodist |
| 1979 | Holiday | 12/21/1979 | Indiana 38-37 Brigham Young |
| 1978 | Holiday | 12/22/1978 | Navy 23-16 Brigham Young |
| 1976 | Capital One | 12/18/1976 | Oklahoma State 49-21 Brigham Young |
| 1974 | Fiesta | 12/28/1974 | Oklahoma State 16-6 Brigham Young |
